Cathedral Building

Another Teaching Blog

258,586 notes

hisnamewasbeanni:

kuryree:

lapizsolarflare:

booksdirect:

“Synonyms for ‘said’.”

woorrdddsssss

“synonyms”
different words still have different meanings/implications
“whimpered” is very different from “laughed”

That’s why no one is claiming that they’re synonyms for each other - only for ‘said’.
No need to nit-pick on such a great resource.

Technically, some sources might still consider them synonyms, which is why it’s important to teach students about the fact that different words, even when they are synonyms, do have different implications and tone from one another.
I learned this the hard way during my first student-teaching experience. When the teacher implemented an illegal word of the week, I thought it would be a great idea to start each week with a small block of time for students to explore that word and its alternatives with a dictionary and thesaurus, the latter which most of the students had never used before. But when students tried substituting words from the thesaurus, they assumed that any word listed as a synonym would do, and we had to talk about drastic differences in tone and meaning.
"But doesn’t a synonym mean it means the same thing?"
"Well…sort of.  It means the same thing to an extent, but then you have to think about what you’re really saying.  That’s the important thing about word choice.  I mean, love and like are synonyms, but do you love your parents the way you love your sneakers?"
"Kind of."
"…okay, do you love your parents the way you love your girlfriend or boyfriend?"
"…ew."
"Exactly."
So, if you want to use this really great resource but the synonyms thing is throwing you off, maybe it’s actually a really great chance for a lesson on word choice and refining your meaning.  There was a really great lesson on this I have saved somewhere posted by another Tumblr Teacher and intended for ESL/ELL — I’ll find it and reblog.

hisnamewasbeanni:

kuryree:

lapizsolarflare:

booksdirect:

“Synonyms for ‘said’.”

woorrdddsssss

“synonyms”

different words still have different meanings/implications

“whimpered” is very different from “laughed”

That’s why no one is claiming that they’re synonyms for each other - only for ‘said’.

No need to nit-pick on such a great resource.

Technically, some sources might still consider them synonyms, which is why it’s important to teach students about the fact that different words, even when they are synonyms, do have different implications and tone from one another.

I learned this the hard way during my first student-teaching experience. When the teacher implemented an illegal word of the week, I thought it would be a great idea to start each week with a small block of time for students to explore that word and its alternatives with a dictionary and thesaurus, the latter which most of the students had never used before. But when students tried substituting words from the thesaurus, they assumed that any word listed as a synonym would do, and we had to talk about drastic differences in tone and meaning.

"But doesn’t a synonym mean it means the same thing?"

"Well…sort of.  It means the same thing to an extent, but then you have to think about what you’re really saying.  That’s the important thing about word choice.  I mean, love and like are synonyms, but do you love your parents the way you love your sneakers?"

"Kind of."

"…okay, do you love your parents the way you love your girlfriend or boyfriend?"

"…ew."

"Exactly."

So, if you want to use this really great resource but the synonyms thing is throwing you off, maybe it’s actually a really great chance for a lesson on word choice and refining your meaning.  There was a really great lesson on this I have saved somewhere posted by another Tumblr Teacher and intended for ESL/ELL — I’ll find it and reblog.

(Source: imgfave.com)

Filed under education writing ela vocabulary

  1. janewayofvoyager reblogged this from marbyco
  2. demongalaxy reblogged this from emmybeth
  3. aboredfreak reblogged this from the-sword-that-soared
  4. ferboscar reblogged this from sweetlyleslie
  5. kittyisotaku reblogged this from hawkesenpai
  6. marbyco reblogged this from babyslime
  7. dresl0ver5 reblogged this from mamabearwaitingforhercub
  8. kawaiiceres reblogged this from kurasuchi and added:
    the list..
  9. babyslime reblogged this from altarflame and added:
    Yeah but that’s just bad writing. “Said” has a central place, especially when the dialogue is the most important part,...
  10. altarflame reblogged this from babyslime and added:
    I kinda disagree; as Neil Gaiman has said (hahaha), “said” disappears into the landscape and flows under readers’ radar...
  11. sobachkawolfofthewaves reblogged this from hazel-graace
  12. caylaleighpaige reblogged this from ileftmyheartinwesteros
  13. toria-broadwaybound reblogged this from theworldwillknowreprise
  14. theactualbest reblogged this from hoorayforbutts
  15. steve135 reblogged this from five-month-bump
  16. minisarucake reblogged this from abby-check
  17. boxofshezza reblogged this from composeandcontort
  18. justagirltryintofindaplacee reblogged this from underwaterelephants08
  19. darkoneelder reblogged this from ileftmyheartinwesteros
  20. composeandcontort reblogged this from elevated-glory
  21. kittymsmith reblogged this from brittswalker
  22. for-k-is-king reblogged this from composersalwaysscore